Broken or Stuck Mailbox Lock? We Repair It or Fit a New One

You have a key, but the lock won't work. We take out broken keys, free stuck or frozen locks and replace bent or loose cams. If the lock can't be saved, a new one goes in with new keys.

What can be done about a broken or stuck mailbox lock?

A broken or stuck mailbox lock can usually be repaired: the broken key comes out, the stuck lock is freed, or the cam is replaced. If the lock is worn or damaged, it is replaced with a new lock and keys. Mailbox Lock and Repair does both, on mailboxes you own and for landlords and HOAs (homeowners associations).

Who owns the mailbox you need fixed?

The mailbox belongs to you, your landlord, a building owner or HOA, or the Post Office, and we only repair privately owned ones. We check photo ID or the owner's written OK before we touch the lock.

Who owns your mailbox?

The brand name on the box does not tell you. Who owns the mailbox decides who may change its lock.

  • You own the home and the mailboxCurbside, wall or door mailboxBook a new lock and keys. The technician checks photo ID with the same address as the mailbox.
  • Your landlord owns itA rented houseYour landlord or property manager orders or approves the work in writing (an email is fine). Book with their written OK, or ask them to book us.
  • A building owner, condo board or HOA (homeowners association) owns itApartment wall panel, privately owned cluster box (one metal unit with many locked mailboxes)Only the owner, HOA or manager can order this work, in writing, and the new keys go to them. Tenants and residents: ask them to book us.
  • The Post Office owns itPost Office-owned cluster box, PO BoxOnly the Post Office can change this lock. Contact your local Post Office. We never work on these boxes.

Not sure? Ask whoever gave you your keys, or your local Post Office.

Why do mailbox locks stick?

Mailbox locks stick because they live outdoors with no cover, and small problems build up inside the cylinder. These are the usual causes:

  • Weather. Water gets into the keyway and freezes in winter. Humid or salty air corrodes the small pins inside.
  • Dirt and dust. Grit packs into the keyway, so the key no longer slides all the way in.
  • A worn key. An old key, or a cheap copy, no longer lifts the pins to the right height, so the cylinder won't turn.
  • A bent cam. The cam (the metal arm on the back of the lock) drags on the mailbox frame, so the key feels stuck.
  • A sagging door. A door that hangs low presses on the cam and binds the lock.

What is safe to try before you call?

A few gentle checks fix some stuck locks without a visit. Stop as soon as the key needs force.

  1. Make sure it is the right key. Mailbox keys look alike, and a near-match can slide in but not turn.
  2. Push the door in gently while you turn the key. This takes pressure off the cam.
  3. In freezing weather, warm the key in your hand for a minute, then try again.
  4. Use a dry lubricant made for locks, such as graphite powder or a PTFE spray. Skip household oil and grease: they catch dust.

Never do these

Never force a key or turn it with pliers: it can snap off inside the lock. Never pour hot water in a frozen lock, because it freezes again. And never drill or pry open a mailbox you don't own. Damaging a mailbox can be a federal crime (18 U.S.C. 1705).

Is it a lock problem or a door problem?

What the key does tells you where the fault is. Use this table to see if you need a lock repair, a new lock or a door repair.

What the symptom usually means
What happensUsual causeThe fix
Key turns, but the door won't stay shutA loose cam screw or a bent camReplace the cam (we do this)
Key won't go in all the wayDirt, or a broken key piece insideClean the lock or take the piece out (we do this)
Key goes in but won't turnA worn key, worn pins or a frozen lockFree the lock, or fit a new lock and keys
The whole lock spins in the doorA loose nut or retaining clipFit a new lock
The door hangs crooked or the hinge is brokenThe door, not the lockA mailbox repair, which we don't do
Parts of a mailbox cam lockAn exploded side view, left to right: the key, the lock face and cylinder, the mailbox door, the nut, the cam and the cam screw, lined up on one center line.123456
  1. 1Key. Turns the lock. A new lock always comes with its own new keys.
  2. 2Lock face and cylinder. The face is what you see on the outside of the door; the cylinder holds the key pins.
  3. 3Mailbox door. The cylinder passes through a hole in the door.
  4. 4Nut or retaining clip. Holds the lock tight against the door from the inside.
  5. 5Cam. The flat metal arm on the back. A quarter turn of the key swings it behind the mailbox frame, and that holds the door shut.
  6. 6Cam screw. Fixes the cam to the end of the cylinder. A loose screw lets the cam slip, so the key turns but the door stays open.
Where each fault sits: the cam and cam screw are on the back of the lock.

What happens when a key breaks off in the lock?

Leave the broken piece alone and don't push it deeper. The technician pulls it out with a thin extractor tool, then tests the lock with your spare key.

If the lock still works, it stays. If the pins or the cylinder were damaged, a new lock with new keys goes in. A lost key is a different job: see lost mailbox key.

Which repairs do we do, and when is a new lock better?

We do three repairs: we take out broken keys, free stuck or frozen locks and replace cams. Anything else means a new lock, because a patched lock fails again.

  • Worn pins or a damaged cylinder: a new lock.
  • A lock that was forced or drilled: a new lock.
  • No working key left: a new lock with new keys.
  • A broken door, hinge or post: not a lock problem, so not a job we take.

What affects the cost of a mailbox lock repair?

A repair depends on what failed: taking out a broken key and replacing a cam are different jobs. If a new lock is needed, the lock your mailbox takes sets most of the price.

What changes the price

  • The lock: a standard mailbox cam lock, or a lock made for an apartment panel or cluster box
  • The mailbox type and maker
  • How many locks we change on one visit
  • A key broken off inside the old lock
  • An after-hours visit

What the price includes

  • The new lock
  • The new keys
  • The visit

You get a free quote before any work starts, and the price is in writing. No fix, no fee: if we can't do the job, you pay nothing.

How does a mailbox lock repair work?

  1. Tell us what the key doesCall or send the form: won't turn, won't go in, broke off, or turns but the door won't lock.
  2. Tell us who owns the mailboxYou, a landlord, HOA or building manager, or the Post Office. We only repair privately owned mailboxes.
  3. Get an arrival timeWe confirm the address and a time window. Please empty the mailbox before the visit. If you can't open it (lost key, stuck lock or a key broken inside), tell us when you book: once the old lock is off, you take out your own mail before any other work. We never handle mail. For an apartment or HOA box, the manager makes sure the box is empty first.
  4. Show photo ID or the written OKPhoto ID with the mailbox address, or the owner's written order for a rental, apartment or HOA box.
  5. Find the causeThe technician checks the key, the cylinder, the cam and the door.
  6. Repair or replaceThe broken key comes out, the lock is freed or the cam is replaced. If the lock can't be saved, a matching new lock goes in.
  7. Test every key with youEach key opens and locks the door before the technician leaves.
  8. Pay and get a receiptYou pay when the job is done. No fix, no fee.

What should you check before you hire anyone?

Check for a written price with every fee, an ownership and ID check and a lock that matches your mailbox maker. The full list works with any company, including us.

  • You get a written price with every fee before any work starts.
  • They ask who owns the mailbox and check photo ID, or the owner's written OK for a rental.
  • They refuse to work on Post Office-owned boxes, the arrow lock (the mail carrier's master lock) and parcel lockers (the bigger locked boxes for packages).
  • They fit a lock that matches your mailbox maker, not a one-size-fits-all part.
  • You get every new key and a receipt.
  • They make no "USPS-approved" or "official" claims about their work. Some mailbox models carry USPS approval, but that says nothing about who changes the lock.
  • Be careful with ads that say "$19 service call" or "from $35". The final bill is often much higher.

Broken and stuck mailbox lock questions

Should I oil a stuck mailbox lock?

Use a dry lubricant made for locks, such as graphite powder or a PTFE spray, not household oil. Oil and grease catch dust and grit, and the lock sticks again, often worse.

My key broke off in the mailbox lock. Do I need a new lock?

Not always. If the broken piece comes out cleanly and the lock still works with your spare key, the lock can stay. If the pins or cylinder were damaged, a new lock with new keys is the fix.

Why does my mailbox key turn but the door won't open or lock?

The cam is usually loose, bent or broken. The key turns the cylinder, but the cam no longer moves with it. Replacing the cam fixes it.

Can you fix a frozen mailbox lock?

Yes. The technician frees the lock and checks the pins for damage. To stop it happening again, put a little dry lock lubricant in the keyway before winter.